Effective Strategies for Managing Large Volumes of Defunct Pages in Google Search Console
Managing a website with a substantial number of outdated or defunct pages can pose significant challenges, especially when dealing with millions of URLs accumulated over years of replatforming and site restructuring. A recent project example involves a client in the Proptech industry with approximately 7 million pages marked as “non-existent” in Google Search Console (GSC). This scenario offers valuable insights into how to approach large-scale URL cleanup and ensure optimal SEO health.
Background
Over a decade, the client’s website underwent multiple replatforms, each introducing new URL structures and navigation schemes. These transitions resulted in numerous issues:
- Multiple URL patterns across different platforms
- Inconsistent or ineffective redirect strategies, often relying on 302 redirects
- Soft 404s indicating pages that appear to be available but return a not-found status from Google’s perspective
- An actual page count of roughly 2.5 million, with only about 800,000 pages currently indexed
The backlink profile further complicates the situation:
- According to Google Search Console, approximately 99% of backlinks point to the homepage
- SEMrush reports a backlink volume five times higher than GSC, with links dispersed across various old and new URL patterns
Strategic Approach
When addressing such a large-scale URL cleanup, it’s essential to establish a clear, data-driven strategy. The goal is to improve crawl efficiency, preserve valuable link equity, and restore the site’s SEO integrity.
- Prioritize Backlink-Driven URL Management
- Focus initially on backlinks identified in GSC, as these are likely to carry the most link equity.
-
Identify high-quality, relevant backlinks pointing to outdated pages that warrant preservation or redirection.
-
Implement Redirects Thoughtfully
- Use 410 (Gone) status codes to indicate permanently defunct pages that no longer offer value, helping search engines efficiently remove these URLs from their index.
-
For remaining pages with relevant content or similar new pages, establish 301 redirects to the most appropriate current URLs.
-
Clean Up and Harden Technical SEO
- Remove or correct soft 404s by ensuring server responses are accurate and pages are correctly marked in the site architecture.
- Audit old route patterns and establish a consistent URL structure moving forward.
-
Enhance site crawl efficiency by submitting updated sitemaps and employing robots.txt directives as needed.
-
Monitor and Adjust
- Regularly track