Optimizing Local SEO for Small Businesses: Should You Hire an Agency or DIY?
For small business owners operating with a single physical location, establishing a strong online presence is crucial for attracting new customers and standing out in local search results. If you’re currently ranking on the first page for a couple of keywords and looking to expand your visibility further, understanding your options becomes vital. One common dilemma is whether to partner with an SEO agency or to take a do-it-yourself (DIY) approach, possibly with some outsourcing.
In this article, we’ll explore the pros and cons of both strategies to help you make an informed decision tailored to your business needs.
Current Context
You operate a local service business with one physical address, with minimal local competition, and have successfully achieved first-page rankings for two keywords. Your goal is to rank on the first page for three or four additional keywords and improve your visibility on local maps.
Options to Consider
- Engaging an SEO Agency
Advantages
- Expertise and Experience: Professional agencies have specialized knowledge of SEO strategies, tools, and current best practices, potentially accelerating your ranking improvements.
- Time Efficiency: Delegating SEO tasks frees up your time to focus on core business operations.
- Consistent Monitoring and Optimization: Agencies often have dedicated resources to track progress and adjust strategies accordingly.
Disadvantages
- Cost: SEO agencies can be expensive, and fees may not always align with the complexity of your needs.
- Transparency Concerns: It can sometimes be unclear exactly what work is being performed, making it harder to assess value.
-
Content Review Required: Final content often needs your review to ensure quality and alignment with your brand voice.
-
DIY Approach with Outsourcing
Advantages
- Full Visibility: You retain control and can closely monitor the strategies being implemented.
- Cost-Effective: Outsourcing specific tasks (such as keyword research, citation building, or content creation) can be more budget-friendly.
- Learning Opportunity: Gaining insight into SEO tactics can empower you to make better-informed decisions in the long run.
Disadvantages
- Learning Curve: SEO can be complex, and mastering the necessary tools and techniques requires time and effort.
- Time Intensive: Managing multiple outsourced tasks can be demanding, especially if you’re unfamiliar with the processes.
- Variable Expertise: Without proper experience, some outsourced