Understanding and Addressing SEO Visibility Fluctuations: Case Study of a Long-Standing Website
In the dynamic landscape of Search Engine Optimization (SEO), website owners often encounter shifts in their site’s visibility within Google’s index. A common concern is when a website ceases to appear in “site:[domain]” searches, yet remains accessible through keyword searches. This situation can be perplexing and warrants a strategic approach to diagnose and resolve potential issues.
Case Overview:
Recently, a website—operating within a competitive niche with considerable historical traffic—experienced a noticeable ranking decline attributed to what is colloquially known as the “Google Dance.” This phenomenon involves fluctuations in rankings and indexing that are often part of Google’s algorithm recalibrations.
Compounding the challenge, the site’s owners observed that their website no longer appears in Google Search when performing a “site:[domain]” query. Interestingly, despite this, the site continues to rank for specific keywords, indicating partial visibility in the index.
Key Observations:
– The website has been actively maintained with updated sitemaps and submissions via Google Search Console.
– Traffic and keyword rankings have declined but not been entirely lost.
– The issue appears localized to site-specific searches rather than overall search visibility.
Potential Causes:
Several factors could contribute to this scenario, including:
– Temporary indexing issues due to Google’s algorithm updates.
– Manual or algorithmic deindexing related to industry-specific or policy compliance issues.
– Technical site problems affecting crawlability or indexation.
– Unintended consequences of recent website changes or updates.
Recommended Strategies for Resolution:
1. Audit Google Search Console:
– Check for manual actions, security issues, or messages indicating penalties.
– Review the Coverage report for pages that are disallowed, excluded, or marked as errors.
- Verify Robots.txt and Noindex Tags:
- Ensure that the robots.txt file does not block essential pages.
-
Confirm that noindex tags have not been inadvertently applied to important pages.
-
Inspect Individual URLs:
-
Use the URL Inspection Tool in Search Console for key pages to see their indexing status and any reported issues.
-
Review Technical SEO Factors:
- Confirm site crawlability.
- Check site speed, mobile-friendliness, and overall health.
-
Ensure sitemap submission is accurate and up-to-date.
-
Monitor Indexing and Ranking Changes:
- Observe if the pages are gradually reappearing in the index