Understanding Why Your Website Ranks Differ in Response to Different Keyword Phrases
If you’re experiencing specific search engine ranking patterns, particularly where your fresh website appears for long-tail or question-based queries but not for more straightforward keyword searches, you’re not alone. Many website owners and SEO professionals have observed that Google’s treatment of various query types influences how and when a site ranks.
Scenario Overview
Imagine launching a new website with an exact domain match (EDM) around a niche topic, such as “unit cost dominance.” Upon indexing, you notice that when searching for the phrase “what is unit cost dominance,” your page appears prominently. Conversely, searching for just “unit cost dominance” yields no results from your site. This discrepancy raises questions about how Google interprets different search queries and what factors affect your site’s visibility.
Key Factors Influencing Search Results
-
Query Type and User Intent
Google often treats long-tail, question-based queries beginning with words like “what is,” “how to,” or “why” as informational or definitional questions. These are generally considered low-competition, high-specificity queries that indicate a desire for a straightforward explanation. As a result, Google may be more inclined to surface fresh or less authoritative sites when ranking these types of queries, especially if the content directly addresses the question. -
Entity Recognition and Keyword Authority
Shorter or more generic keywords, such as “unit cost dominance,” are typically regarded as entity or head terms. Ranking for these queries usually requires higher domain authority, more backlinks, and an established online presence. Since your website is new, it’s likely still building the trust signals necessary for ranking in these broader keyword searches. -
Freshness and Content Relevance (Query Deserves Fresh Content – QDF)
Google’s algorithms sometimes favor newly published content for specific queries, especially those that are trending or recent. Definitional queries often fall into this category because users seek current straightforward explanations. Over time, as your site gains authority, rankings for the broader keywords should improve.
Implications for Your SEO Strategy
Understanding that Google differentiates between query types can help you tailor your content and SEO efforts:
-
Focus on Creating Comprehensive Informational Content:
As your site is new, producing well-structured, authoritative content targeting definitional queries (“what is unit cost dominance”) can help establish relevance and improve overall visibility. -
Build Domain Authority for Broader Keywords: